When a business is new, or has just had a bad week of reviews, the people closest to you often offer to help. "I'll leave you five stars." "I'll get the whole team to post one." It feels harmless. They know your work is good, after all.
The problem is that reviews are meant to come from customers, and both the platforms and the law treat reviews from insiders differently. This guide explains what Google, Yelp and the FTC say, where the real risks are, and what your team and family can do to help instead. It is general information, not legal advice.
The short answer
| Who | Can they leave a review? |
|---|---|
| You, as the owner or a manager | No. Google treats it as a conflict of interest, and in the US the FTC rule requires a clear disclosure if an officer or manager writes one |
| Current or former employees | No on Google. Its policy names current or former employment as a conflict of interest |
| Close family | No on Google. Its policy lists familial relationships as a conflict of interest |
| Friends who are also genuine customers | Grey area. If they paid for and used your service like anyone else, their experience is real, but a close personal tie can still count as a conflict |
| Competitors | No. Google prohibits posting content on a competitor's listing to undermine its reputation |
What Google's policy says
Google's Maps user contributed content policy prohibits "content that is based on a conflict of interest." It explains that a conflict of interest "may include current or former employment, a contractual or consultory relationship, or other professional or personal affiliations," and gives examples "such as industry competitors, familial relationships, etc."
So on Google, a review from your staff, your partner, your parents or your business coach breaks the rules, even if every word is true. Google also prohibits review incentives, so offering staff a bonus or a day off for collecting or posting reviews is off limits too.
Reviews that break the policy can be removed, and Google can take action against the business profile as well. If your reviews suddenly vanish, insider reviews are one possible reason. Our guide on why Google reviews disappear covers the others.
What Yelp says
Yelp asks businesses not to solicit reviews at all, from anyone. That rules out asking your team or family to post. Yelp's recommendation software also filters many reviews it cannot trust, so insider reviews often end up in the "not recommended" section anyway. See why Yelp reviews are "not recommended".
What the FTC rule says
In the US, the FTC consumer reviews rule (16 CFR Part 465) has been in force since October 2024, with civil penalties of up to $51,744 per violation (2024 figure). Section 465.5 deals with insider reviews. In plain English:
- Officers and managers must not write a consumer review of their own business, or its products or services, without "a clear and conspicuous disclosure" of their relationship to the business.
- Asking staff and relatives for reviews is a problem when an officer or manager solicits reviews from immediate relatives, employees or agents, a review then appears without disclosure of the relationship, and the manager encouraged them not to disclose, did not tell them to disclose, or knew or should have known an undisclosed review appeared and did not take steps to fix it.
- Generalized requests to customers are fine. The rule specifically excludes "generalized solicitations to purchasers for them to post reviews about their experiences."
Note what this means in practice. The FTC rule allows an insider review if the relationship is clearly disclosed, but Google's policy does not allow it at all. Following the stricter platform rule keeps you safe on both.
Our guide to the FTC's fake review rule covers the other parts of the rule.
Common situations
"My employee bought something from us. Can they review it?"
On Google, no. Employment is a conflict of interest whatever they bought. On a platform that allows it, they would need to clearly say they work for you.
"My mum wants to leave a review."
Thank her and ask her not to. A review from a family member is the kind of thing competitors and platforms spot quickly, and one removed review can make the honest ones look less credible.
"I accidentally sent a review request to my whole contact list, including family."
Tell the people who are not customers to ignore it, and if any of them already posted, ask them to delete their review. Under the FTC rule, taking remedial steps when you learn about an undisclosed insider review matters.
"A former employee left us a bad review."
Google's conflict of interest rule applies to former employees too, so you can report it. Our guide on when a former employee leaves a bad review explains how to report it and how to reply in the meantime.
How your team can help without breaking the rules
Your staff are still your best source of reviews. They just help by asking customers, not by reviewing.
- Ask every customer the same way. Staff can hand over a card, point to a QR code at the counter, or mention the review link at the end of a job. Selectively asking only happy customers is review gating, which Google prohibits.
- Never write a review for a customer. Not even if the customer says "just put something nice for me."
- No rewards tied to reviews. No staff bonuses for review counts, and no discounts for customers who post.
- Let staff reply on the business's behalf, not as themselves. A reply from the business is not a review, so your team can draft and post replies through the owner account.
- Family and friends can share, not post. They can recommend you by word of mouth, share your Google profile with people who have used you, or follow you on social media.
A short staff policy you can copy
Reviews must come only from genuine customers. Staff, owners and their families must not post reviews of [Business] on any site. We ask every customer for a review in the same way and never offer anything in return. If you see a review you think breaks these rules, tell [manager] rather than replying.
Checklist
- [ ] No owner, manager, employee or relative has reviewed the business
- [ ] Any existing insider reviews have been deleted by their authors
- [ ] Staff know how to ask customers, and never post reviews themselves
- [ ] No bonus, prize or discount is linked to reviews
- [ ] Everyone is asked for a review the same way
- [ ] The staff policy above is written down and shared
How Reputfy helps
Reputfy sends review requests the same way to every customer and keeps a record of who was asked and when, which is useful evidence that your reviews come from real customers through a fair process. Your review link also works as a QR code for the counter. Reviews collected through Reputfy are sealed with a SHA-256 fingerprint, timestamped with OpenTimestamps, and your Reputfy seal can be checked by anyone at the seal check page. Sign up free and try every feature for 7 days.



