"Slipped on a wet floor and hurt my back. Nobody even asked if I was okay." A review like this is different from a complaint about slow service or a cold coffee. Someone says they were hurt, and every future customer reading it wonders whether your place is safe.
It is also a review where a careless reply can cause real trouble. What you write in public can be read by the customer, their lawyer, your insurer and a judge. This guide explains what to do before you reply, how to word a reply that shows care without admitting fault, and what to leave out. It is general information, not legal advice. If a claim is possible, speak to your insurer and a lawyer before you post anything.
Why you should still reply
Silence looks like you do not care that someone was hurt. In the BrightLocal Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, 97% of consumers said they read reviews and 89% said they expect businesses to respond. A short, caring reply tells the next reader that you take safety seriously and that you reached out.
The goal is not to win the argument. It is to show concern, move the conversation offline and protect your position while the facts are checked.
First steps, before you write anything
Work through these in order. Most take minutes, and they matter more than the reply itself.
- Screenshot the review with the date, the star rating and the reviewer's name.
- Check your records. Is there an incident or accident report for that day? A booking, receipt or class sign-in under that name?
- Talk to the staff on shift. Write down what they saw, what was said and whether first aid was offered.
- Keep any evidence. CCTV footage is often overwritten after a few days, so save the relevant clip now. Keep cleaning logs, maintenance records and photos of the area.
- Tell your insurer. Many business insurance policies expect early notice of a possible claim. Some insurers also want to see a reply before it goes live.
- Fix any hazard now. If there is a loose step, a leaking fridge or a broken chair, deal with it today, whatever you think of the review.
- Decide who replies. One person, usually the owner or manager, should handle the reply and any follow-up contact.
If the review mentions a lawyer, a lawsuit or "reporting you", read when a review threatens to sue or report you as well.
What a good reply does
| Do | Don't |
|---|---|
| Say you are sorry to hear they were hurt | Say "we're sorry we caused your injury" |
| Show concern for their wellbeing | Argue about whether it happened |
| Invite them to contact a named person | Ask for medical details in public |
| Mention safety checks in general terms | Promise compensation or refunds |
| Keep it short | Describe their behaviour, footwear or health |
There is a real difference between "We're sorry to hear you were hurt" and "We're sorry our wet floor hurt you." The first shows care. The second states what happened and who was at fault, before anyone has checked. Keep your wording on the side of care.
Example replies
Slip or fall on the premises
We're very sorry to hear you were hurt during your visit, and we hope you're feeling better. The safety of everyone who comes in matters to us, and we'd like to understand what happened. Please contact me directly at manager@example.com or on 555-0100. Sam, manager
Injury during a class, session or treatment
Thank you for telling us, and we're sorry to hear you were injured. We take this seriously and would like to talk with you directly rather than here. Please call the studio on 555-0100 and ask for Priya, who looks after member safety.
When you can find no record of the visit
We're sorry to read this. We can't find a visit or an incident report matching this date, and we'd like to look into it properly. Please contact us at hello@example.com with any details you can share so we can follow up.
When there is already a claim in progress
We're sorry to hear about your experience. Because this matter is being handled through the proper channels, we can't discuss it here, but we wish you a full recovery.
That last one is short on purpose. Once a claim is open, a public reply should say very little. Agree the wording with your insurer or lawyer.
What never to write
- Admissions of fault. "The floor had just been mopped and the sign wasn't out" may be true, but it belongs in your incident report, not in a public reply.
- Blame. "You weren't looking where you were going" or "you were wearing the wrong shoes" will read badly and may be quoted back to you.
- Medical opinions. Do not comment on their injury, how serious it is or what treatment they need.
- Offers of money. Compensation is a private conversation, usually with your insurer involved.
- Personal details. Do not confirm their name, booking, health or anything about their visit.
- Threats. The FTC consumer reviews rule, in force since October 2024, bans using unfounded legal threats or intimidation to stop or remove reviews, with civil penalties up to $51,744 per violation (2024 figure).
- A second public reply. If they argue back, take it offline.
If a review names a staff member as responsible, see when a bad review names one of your employees.
Healthcare, fitness and beauty businesses: extra care
If you are a clinic, therapist, dentist, pharmacy or similar, the rules on patient privacy are stricter. In the United States, HHS announced in December 2022 that a California dental practice paid $23,000 to settle potential HIPAA violations after it disclosed patient information while responding to online reviews. Even confirming that someone is a patient can be a problem. Keep replies completely general.
Gyms, studios, salons and spas should also avoid confirming what service someone had. "We're sorry to hear this, please contact us directly" is enough.
If you think the review is not genuine
Sometimes an injury review comes from someone who was never there, or arrives alongside other suspicious reviews. You can report a review that breaks the platform's rules, for example one from a person who was never a customer. Collect your evidence first, report it through the platform, and still post a calm, general reply while you wait. Do not accuse the reviewer of lying in public.
Checklist
- [ ] Review screenshotted with date and name
- [ ] Incident records, staff notes and CCTV saved
- [ ] Insurer told, if your policy requires it
- [ ] Any hazard fixed
- [ ] Reply shows care without admitting or denying fault
- [ ] No medical, personal or booking details
- [ ] Named contact offered for a private conversation
- [ ] Wording checked with your insurer or lawyer if a claim is mentioned
- [ ] Only one public reply
Make safety visible before the next review
The best answer to an injury review is a business where incidents are rare and handled well. Keep a simple incident log, train staff to offer help and write down what happened, and check high-risk areas such as entrances, stairs and wet floors on a schedule. When something does go wrong, a quick, kind conversation on the day often prevents the review in the first place.
How Reputfy helps
Reputfy drafts replies with AI, and nothing is posted until you approve it, so you or your insurer can check the wording first. Reviews collected through Reputfy are sealed with a SHA-256 fingerprint and timestamped with OpenTimestamps, so you have a dependable record of exactly what was posted and when. Sign up free and try every feature for 7 days.


