Blog · Rules

FTC review rule enforcement: 8 things the warning letters tell small businesses

The FTC's first warning letters under the Consumer Review Rule signal active enforcement, with penalties up to $53,088 per violation. 8 lessons for businesses that collect reviews.

Reputfy Editorial··6 min read

The FTC's Consumer Review Rule took effect on October 21, 2024. On December 22, 2025, FTC staff sent warning letters to ten unnamed companies about possible violations, the agency's first public step in enforcing it. Throughout 2026 law firms have described the letters as the start of an enforcement era, not a one-off.

Here is what the letters and the commentary around them mean for a small business. For the rule itself, start with the FTC's fake review rule, explained. This is general information, not legal advice.

1. Penalties are real money

Violations can bring civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation, and the FTC noted these can quickly add up. One fake review campaign can mean many violations.

2. The FTC acts on complaints

According to the letter template, the warnings were based on consumer complaints and information the companies themselves had provided. Unhappy customers, ex-employees and competitors can all report you.

3. Response times are short

Recipients were asked to confirm in writing within about five business days what steps they had taken to comply. Have your process documented before anyone asks.

4. Incentives only for positive reviews are out

The letters flag offering incentives in exchange for positive reviews. Asking for honest reviews is fine; tying a reward to stars is not. See incentivized reviews rules.

5. Suppressing negative reviews counts

Commentators, including Bazaarvoice and law firm Benesch, highlighted the suppression of negative reviews. Filtering unhappy customers away from public review sites is review gating.

6. Insider reviews need disclosure

Reviews from employees, owners or relatives must be clearly disclosed. See can employees and family review your business?.

7. Fake social proof is included

The rule also covers buying fake followers or views to misrepresent influence.

8. Your tools are part of your practice

If your review software filters who is asked, or your agency buys reviews, it is still your business on the hook. Choose tools that ask every customer the same way. See our list of the best FTC-compliant review request tools.

A quick compliance checklist

  • [ ] Every customer is asked for a review the same way
  • [ ] No rewards tied to positive reviews
  • [ ] Staff and family reviews disclosed or not posted
  • [ ] No buying, writing or swapping reviews
  • [ ] Negative reviews never hidden on your own site
  • [ ] Your process is written down

How Reputfy helps

Reputfy asks every customer the same way, keeps a record of every request and seals each review with a public fingerprint, so you can show your process is fair. Sign up free and try every feature for 7 days.