A glowing review is the best marketing copy you will ever get, and you did not have to write it. So it is natural to want to put it on your homepage, in a flyer or in a social media ad.
You usually can. But once a review leaves the review site and appears in your own marketing, it becomes your advertising, and the rules on advertising apply. This guide explains what US rules say about quoting reviews, how to edit them fairly, and how to show them on your website without misleading anyone. It is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ outside the US, so check locally.
The rules that apply
Two sets of FTC rules matter here.
| Rule | What it covers |
|---|---|
| FTC Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR Part 465) | Fake reviews and testimonials, insider reviews, review suppression, and misrepresenting the reviews you display. In force since October 2024 |
| FTC Endorsement Guides (16 CFR Part 255), updated in 2023 | How endorsements and testimonials can be used in advertising, including honesty and disclosure of connections |
The consumer reviews rule carries civil penalties of up to $51,744 per violation (2024 figure). The Endorsement Guides are guidance rather than a rule, but the FTC uses them to judge whether advertising is deceptive.
What you can do
- Quote real reviews from real customers. A review is a testimonial, and testimonials are allowed when they reflect the customer's honest experience.
- Pick your favourite reviews for an ad. An advert is understood to show you at your best. Choosing positive quotes for a flyer is normal.
- Shorten a review, as long as the meaning does not change.
- Link to the source, so readers can see the full review where it was posted.
What you cannot do
- Change the meaning. "The food was great, shame about the service" cannot become "The food was great" if the ad implies the whole visit was good. The Endorsement Guides say an endorsement must reflect the honest opinion of the endorser and cannot be presented out of context.
- Write or invent testimonials. The consumer reviews rule bans fake reviews and testimonials, including ones attributed to people who do not exist or who did not have the experience described.
- Hide a connection. If the reviewer is an employee, a relative or someone you paid or gave free products to, the connection needs a clear disclosure. See can employees and family review your business.
- Pretend selected reviews are all your reviews. This is the point most owners miss, and it has its own section below.
The review page trap
Many businesses have a "Reviews" or "What our customers say" page. If that page only shows five-star reviews but implies it shows all of them, it can mislead.
The consumer reviews rule says a business that controls a website where consumer reviews are displayed must not misrepresent that those reviews represent most or all of the reviews submitted, when reviews are being suppressed based on their rating or negative sentiment. In plain terms: a hand-picked page is fine if it is clearly presented as hand-picked. A page that looks like a complete feed while quietly filtering out bad reviews is not.
| Page setup | Risk |
|---|---|
| "A few of our favourite reviews" with five quotes | Low. Clearly a selection |
| A widget showing your full review feed, good and bad | Low. Shows everything |
| "All reviews" or a rating summary that leaves out low ratings | High. Implies completeness while filtering |
| An average rating calculated only from the reviews you chose | High. The number misleads |
The same thinking applies to how you collect reviews in the first place. Asking only happy customers is review gating, which Google prohibits. See review gating is banned.
Editing a review fairly
When you shorten a review for an ad, use this test: would the customer agree that the quote says what they meant?
| Original review | Fair quote | Unfair quote |
|---|---|---|
| "Took a while to get an appointment, but the repair was excellent and fairly priced." | "The repair was excellent and fairly priced." | "Excellent... fast" |
| "Not the cheapest, but worth every penny." | "Worth every penny." | "Not the cheapest" removed and replaced with "Great prices" |
| "Lovely staff. The room was tired but clean." | "Lovely staff." | "Lovely... room" |
Never fix a review's grammar in a way that changes its tone, and never merge two reviews into one quote.
Ask permission, even when you don't strictly have to
Whether you need the customer's consent to reuse a public review depends on the platform's terms and local law, and it is not always clear. Asking is good practice anyway. It also gives you a chance to confirm the customer is happy to have their name shown.
Hi [first name], thank you again for your lovely review. Would you be happy for us to quote it on our website, with your first name and last initial? No problem at all if not. [Business name]
Keep a record of the answer. Use first names and initials rather than full names unless the customer says otherwise, and never add details they did not share, such as their street or what they bought.
Special care for regulated businesses
Health practices, lawyers, financial advisers and other regulated professions often have extra rules on testimonials in advertising, set by licensing boards or regulators. Before you quote patient or client reviews, check those rules. For health care, also remember that a patient choosing to post a review does not mean you can add details about their care. See reviews for doctors and dentists.
Checklist
- [ ] Every quoted review comes from a real customer
- [ ] Shortened quotes keep the original meaning
- [ ] Any employee, family or paid connection is clearly disclosed
- [ ] A selected reviews page is labelled as a selection
- [ ] Any rating or "all reviews" display includes low ratings too
- [ ] Customers were asked before their name was used
- [ ] Regulated professions have checked their own testimonial rules
How Reputfy helps
Reviews collected through Reputfy are sealed with a SHA-256 fingerprint and timestamped with OpenTimestamps, so a quote on your website can be traced back to an unchanged original. The Reputfy seal follows six published criteria, and anyone can check it on the seal check page. Review requests go to every customer the same way, with a record kept, so your reviews come from a fair process. Sign up free and try every feature for 7 days.



