GatherUp is a well-known name for agencies and multi-location businesses that want reviews plus customer feedback. Reputfy is a review platform built around trust: reviews sealed with a public fingerprint, a website seal checked live, and AI reply drafts you approve before anything is posted.
This comparison looks at what each costs, what each does best, and which kind of business should pick which. If you are weighing several tools, see our list of GatherUp alternatives too.
Prices checked November 2026 from vendor pricing pages and third-party listings named in each section. Vendors change prices often, so confirm with the vendor before you buy. Reputfy publishes this guide, so we have listed where each competitor is the better choice.
Quick verdict
- Choose GatherUp if you want feedback surveys and reviews together and run many client or location accounts.
- Choose Reputfy if you want more honest reviews, faster replies and proof your reviews are real, without a long contract or a per-location suite you will only half use.
Side by side
| Reputfy | GatherUp | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Local and independent businesses that want trusted reviews | Agencies and multi-location businesses that want reviews plus customer feedback |
| Pricing model | Free sign-up, paid plans on the pricing page | Starts around $99 a month |
| Contract | Monthly billing, cancel any time | Monthly |
| Trial | 7 days of every feature | Free trial |
| Review monitoring | 10+ to 100+ platforms, by plan | Yes |
| AI reply drafts | Yes, approved by you before posting | Varies by plan |
| Sealed, tamper-evident reviews | Yes, public timestamped fingerprint | No |
| Website seal checked live | Yes, six criteria | No |
| Consumer seal check extension | Yes, free for Chrome | No |
Where GatherUp is the better choice
GatherUp blends review requests with NPS-style feedback, which helps businesses hear problems privately as well as collect public reviews. Agencies like its white-label options.
Choose GatherUp if you want feedback surveys and reviews together and run many client or location accounts.
Where Reputfy comes out ahead
Add-ons and setup fees raise the real cost, and feedback-first flows need care so they never become review gating. There is no public review seal that customers can check live.
- Sealed reviews. Every review collected through Reputfy gets a public, timestamped fingerprint, so anyone can check it has not been edited since it was written. See how review verification works.
- A seal that is checked live. The Reputfy Seal on your website is checked live against six criteria, including a verified owner, recent sealed reviews and replies to critical reviews. A copied image fails the check. Read how to check if a trust badge is real.
- The same ask to every customer. Reputfy sends the same request to every customer and keeps a record, which keeps you clear of review gating and in line with the FTC fake review rule.
- AI reply drafts you approve. Reputfy drafts a reply to each review, and nothing is posted until you approve it. Start from our reply templates by star rating.
- Stickers and QR codes. Print your review link as a QR sticker for counters, receipts and job cards. See QR code review cards.
- Proof you own your website. Verify your domain with a DNS TXT record, so the seal can only be shown on sites you control.
Pricing and real costs
GatherUp. Small Business $99 a month and Multi Location from $60 per location, per Toolradar. Costbench lists Listings Hub at $40 per location and a $250 setup fee, and PricingSaaS lists Review Defense from $45 per location.
Reputfy. Reputfy is free to sign up. Every paid feature can be tried for 7 days; a card is needed to start the trial, and nothing is charged until the trial ends. Current plans are on the pricing page, and you can cancel from the billing portal at any time.
When you compare, add up the whole first year: setup or onboarding fees, per-location charges, extra seats, message caps and whether you must prepay. A tool that looks cheap per month can cost more once a 12-month commitment and add-ons are included.
Which should you choose?
| If you.. | Pick |
|---|---|
| Want feedback surveys and reviews together and run many client or location accounts | GatherUp |
| Want customers to be able to check your reviews are real | Reputfy |
| Want the same review request sent to every customer, on record | Reputfy |
| Want replies drafted for you but never posted without approval | Reputfy |
| Want to try everything before paying | Reputfy (7-day trial) |
How to try Reputfy alongside GatherUp
You do not need to switch everything at once. Many businesses keep their existing tool for a week and run Reputfy beside it:
- Sign up free and add your business.
- Connect your review profiles so Reputfy can monitor them.
- Send your next batch of customers a review request by text or email.
- Compare the replies Reputfy drafts with the ones you write today.
If you would like a walkthrough first, book a demo.
Related reading
- How to respond to a negative review (without making it worse)
- How to get more Google reviews without breaking the rules
- Review gating is banned. Here's what to do instead
- The FTC's fake review rule, explained for small businesses
- How to ask customers for reviews by text and email
How Reputfy helps
Reputfy monitors your reviews across Google, Facebook, Yelp and many more platforms, drafts every reply with AI for you to approve, and seals each review it collects with a public fingerprint so customers can trust it. Sign up free and try every feature for 7 days.


